Silencer Shop
vs.
Silencer Central

Silencer Shop vs Silencer Central: Which Suppressor Dealer is Right For You?

Compare Silencer Shop and Silencer Central on pricing, process, and customer service to choose the best suppressor dealer for your needs.

One thing is clear:
Silencer Shop is the better, faster, and more trusted way to buy a silencer.

By the Numbers
  • 99.5%

    Accuracy Rating

  • 66,000+

    Trustpilot Reviews

  • 6,000+

    Local Gunshops Nationwide

Quick Comparison

When you’re ready to buy a suppressor, one of your decisions isn’t just which silencer to buy—it’s who you trust with your time, money, and rights. Silencer Shop is the largest distributor of silencers in America, and runs the most trusted and most trafficked suppressor website, with a nationwide network of partnered local dealers. Silencer Central seems convenient at first glance, but inked prints, notarization, and extended shipping windows add time and money you won’t spend with Silencer Shop. On paper, both companies promise to make the process easy. But real-world numbers, buyer stories, and side-by-side analysis make one thing clear:

Silencer Shop is the better, faster, and more trusted way to buy a silencer.

Silencer Shop

  • Founded: 2010, Texas
  • Largest, highest-rated suppressor dealer in the U.S.
  • 4.8★ Trustpilot (66,000+ reviews)
  • 4.9★ Google (23,000+ reviews)
  • More 5-star reviews than Silencer Central has total reviews—period
  • Supports 6,000+ local gun shops; industry leader in tech, service, and 2A support
  • ATF eForms Speed – Digital filing gets you in line faster, pickup as soon as your stamp is approved.

Silencer Central

  • Founded: 2005, South Dakota
  • Known for direct-to-door shipping and BANISH suppressors
  • 4.6★ Trustpilot (27,300+ reviews)
  • 4.8★ Google (8,000+ reviews)
  • Fewer reviews, lower ratings, and zero local support
  • Shipping Delays – Even after approval, add 7+ days for CLEO notice and mail delivery.

*Review ratings as of August 2025

Buying a Suppressor Comparison

Silencer Shop

Simpler, Faster, Better

  • Buy online, by phone, or at your local dealer. Choose from 30+ top brands—Q, Dead Air, SureFire, Rugged, SilencerCo, HUXWRX, and more.
  • Handle paperwork digitally. Visit a Silencer Shop Kiosk at a local dealer for quick, secure fingerprinting (5 minutes, one time ever).
  • Fast, easy trust setup. The Single Shot Trust is $24.95, digital, and requires no notary to establish.
  • Track your status. Review, sign, and certify everything digitally. Local dealers keep you updated and walk you through pickup—no waiting for “mystery” shipping windows.
  • No 7-Day Delay. Support your local dealer and skip the 7-day legal hold for mail deliveries.
  • ATF eForms speed - Because Silencer Shop digitizes the process, you’re in line faster—and picking up your suppressor as soon as the ATF stamp hits.

Silencer Central

Mail, Wait, Repeat

  • Buy online or by phone. Seem to push shoppers toward BANISH suppressors (their in-house brand), with fewer third-party options.
  • Old-school paperwork. After purchase, you wait for a mail-in fingerprint kit. You roll ink prints yourself and send them back—a step that adds a week or more before the process even starts.
  • “Free” trust with extra steps. The included trust must be notarized—a trip out of your way and extra cost for many buyers. If you decide to refund this, you’ll be charged $250.
  • No local support. Everything is done by mail or online; you’re on your own until they call.
  • Shipping delays - Even after approval, your suppressor isn’t shipped until Silencer Central notifies your local CLEO and waits at least another 7 days as required by law for delivery by mail.

Silencer Shop stands out as the clear winner for three big reasons: speed, choice, and support. Speed comes from our one-and-done kiosk fingerprints, fully digital trust setup, and direct local pickup—no extra 7-day mail hold. Choice means 30+ top brands without focusing on an in-house brand so you get the right suppressor for your needs. And support comes from our nationwide dealer network, giving you real people to guide you every step instead of leaving you to figure it out alone. The result is a faster, easier, and more transparent suppressor-buying experience from start to finish.

The Bottom Line: More Americans choose Silencer Shop—and have better experiences when they do.

Silencer Shop PRO PICKS

  1. Save $200

    On select suppressors for a short time.

    See All
  2. Q

    Trash Panda 7.62

    $1,050

    5 reviews

    View
  3. CGS

    Hyperion .30-Cal

    $1,379

    63 reviews

    View
  4. Q

    SOUTHPAW 556

    $1149

    1 reviews

    View
  5. B&T

    SRBS762-DM Titanium

    $1,379

    28 reviews

    View
  6. B&T

    Print-XH RBS SC 556

    $1050

    5 reviews

    View
  7. CAT

    Dirty Dave Ti HUB

    $1,190

    2 reviews

    View
  8. B&T

    PRINT-XH RBS 5.56

    $1,050

    11 reviews

    View

WHY BUYERS ACTUALLY PREFER SILENCER SHOP

Buying a suppressor should be simple, fast, and on your terms. But too often the process feels like a mess of paperwork, long waits, and being pushed into options that don’t actually fit what you want. That’s where Silencer Shop steps in. With the highest customer ratings in the industry, the easiest paperwork system, and the biggest selection of silencers from every top brand, we make sure you get what you need quickly and easily.

1. Unmatched Customer Ratings (and Volume)

Silencer Shop
4.8 on Trustpilot • 66,000+ buyers 4.9 on Google • 23,000+ buyers More 5-star reviews than Silencer Central has total reviews
Silencer Central
4.6 on Trustpilot • 27,294 reviews 4.8 on Google • 8,185 reviews

2. Faster, Easier Paperwork

  • One trip to a kiosk or quick mail-in (if needed)—no repeated fingerprinting or delays
  • No notary required for trusts, just click and sign
  • Local dealer support: If you hit a snag, you talk to a real person in your town, not just a call center or chatbot
  • When ATF approves, you can pick up your suppressor immediately—no extra waits for law enforcement notifications or shipping

3. Supports Local Gun Shops and Your Rights

  • Every time you use Silencer Shop, your local dealer gets paid—a big win for small businesses and the gun community
  • Silencer Shop donates millions to Second Amendment causes and fights anti-gun lawsuits (including suing the ATF itself)
  • Silencer Central does not support your local gun store (they cut them out for extra profit), nor do they have a track record of defending your rights

4. More Choice, More Control

  • You’re not forced into one brand, one process, or one way of buying
  • Add trustees to your trust after approval—no extra headaches
  • How to Buy Guide and deep blog library, for every question, every step

Frequently Asked Questions

OTHERS JUST SELL SILENCERS

...WE SELL YOU THE RIGHT ONE

WE GIVE A SHHH...

Silencer Shop icon

NO BREADCRUMBS